Rednoah, that did it. I couldn't find that anywhere! Thank you SOOO much for your help. This was driving me crazy!

I was matching a show and selected the option "select and remember for next time" and now no matter what I do I can't get it to give me the list of shows to pick from again when matching. It just auto matches to the wrong show. I've deleted my temp files and rebooted already and it's still matching ...